CO129-454 - Acting Governor Claud Severn - 1919 [4-6] — Page 190

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All

|

186

withdrawing any imputations in the letter from "Wireless the

paragraph maintains them.

It is submitted that the allegations which are complained

of are not comment or fair criticism but are allegations of

fact, that is of negligence and are libellous.

It is thought it will be possible to secure witnesses

who will give evidence as to the impression they gathered

from the letter, namely that it charged the plaintiff with

negligence in the performance of his duty.

It will be noticed that the defendants published the

libel in two separate publications one circulating in the

Colony and generally throughout the Far East. The other

circulating amongst a, perhaps, wider audience at home,

It

is naturally particularly distasteful to the plaintiff that

his relatives and friends at home should get the impression

that he neglected the duties of a responsible post.

The Extract from the outlook" was sent anonymously to

the plaintiff. It appears to be a good sample of fair

comment on similar lines,

The following references to "odgers on Libel" may

of assistance to Counsel.

Separate publications

P. 151

Publication onus.

p.152, 155,

Procuration.

p.161, 164.

-14-

be

Every publication of a libel is a

distinct and separate act and a

distinct and separate cause of

action.

The onus lies on the plaintiff.

Every one who requests or procures

allo ther to publish a libel ie

auswerable as though he wrote it

himself.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.